Friday, May 02, 2014

Ghetto isn't always scary

One of my friends posted a link to an article on my facebook page, about upward mobility in the African-American community.

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/politics/2014/04/desean_jackson_richard_sherman_and_black_american_economic_mobility_why.html?wpisrc=obnetwork


Many of the circumstances mentioned in the article can go beyond "black and white".


But let's start with the following.



“We didn’t run from where we grew up. We aren’t afraid to be associated with the people who came up with us.” 
That’s Richard Sherman of the Seattle Seahawks writing in defense of his friend, DeSean Jackson, who was cut from the Philadelphia Eagles amid reports of gang ties. Sherman isn’t trying to litigate the allegations or exonerate Jackson—he doesn’t know the details. But he doesn’t think it’s wrong for Jackson to associate with the men from his childhood. 
And why would it be? Yes, some of them have criminal records—and for some, that includes gang activity—but leaving home is hard, and the social distance of wealth makes it even harder. As Sherman writes, “In desperate times for people who come from desperate communities, your friends become your family. I wouldn’t expect DeSean to ‘distance himself’ from anybody, as so many people suggest pro athletes ought to do despite having no understanding of what that means.”


These circumstances aren't  limited to African-Americans.  These circumstances are common to anyone who grew up in the ghetto.

I grew up in Kalihi, where are multiple public housing complexes, all built to serve low-income families. I grew up in one of the smaller, lesser-known public housing complexes Lanakila (officially called Puahala Homes, but come on...... only bureaucrats call it that).

If you grow up in such communities, guaranteed you will be going to elementary school with kids who end up joining gangs and sentenced to prison. 

To the people who didn't grow up in the inner city, they see "all gang members are a menace". To those of us who grew up in the inner city, we remember them as classmates who made us laugh back at elementary school.   We remember them as kids we walked with on the way home from school.  We remember them from before they started the life of drugs, alcohol, gang rivalries and prison sentences.

This is what Richard Sherman was referring to when he mentioned how hard it is for NFL players (and NBA players too) to distance themselves from childhood friends who are in a gang. 

Now, as time goes by, you do get distanced from former classmates. 

But if my elementary classmates who became gang-affiliated sees me in public, I'll be like "what's up homie, I haven't seen you in a long time". I'm not greeting them as "gang member", I'm greeting them as former classmates from elementary school, or former residents of our childhood community! 

Now obviously, if they want to invite to "go drinking", "smoke some weed" or some other illegal activity, I'll just tell them "no thanks", and remind them that I got real-life adult responsibilities I have to take care of. 

--------

Now, back to the article I mentioned earlier

I don’t know if Sherman sees it or not—my hunch is that he does—but in a few sentences, he’s put his finger on the pulse of something overlooked in our discussions of poverty and economic mobility as they relate to black Americans: neighborhood. Sherman’s experience of being pulled back to a poor neighborhood, even as he accumulates wealth, is common among blacks.
The difference for ordinary black Americans, as opposed to NFL stars, is that this has been a powerful driver of downward mobility. Just a quick comparison of black and white neighborhoods is enough to illustrate the particular challenges that face black families as they reach for middle class, or try to keep their position.
The key fact is this: Even after you adjust for income and education, black Americans are more likely than any other group to live in neighborhoods with substantial pockets of poverty.

and 

It’s tempting to attribute this to the income disparity between blacks and whites. Since blacks are more likely to be poor, it stands to reason that they’re more likely to live in poor neighborhoods. But the fact of large-scale neighborhood poverty holds true for higher-income black Americans as well. Middle-class blacks are far more likely than middle-class whites to live in areas with significant amounts of poverty. Among today’s cohort of middle- and upper-class blacks, about half were raised in neighborhoods of at least 20 percent poverty. Only 1 percent of today’s middle- and upper-class whites can say the same.
In short, if you took two children—one white, one black—and gave them parents with similar jobs, similar educations, and similar values, the black child would be much more likely to grow up in a neighborhood with higher poverty, worse schools, and more violence.

While the article compares Americans of European and African ancestries, it goes beyond "black and white".

It mentioned about middle-income African-Americans who haven't left the ghetto even though they could afford to move out.

Some people might have a hard time understanding that. But I think I know why.

For those who never lived in the inner-city, they think that "ghettos are scary". After all, that's how it's portrayed on TV.

For those of us who grew up in the ghetto, we  don't just see the ghetto as a "scary place", it's our childhood home. 

 We have some good childhood memories from the place, had some uncles & aunties (not always genetically-related)  in the hood , know all the mom & pop stores....... so even if we don't like the drugs and violence, we see something more than that!


I remember back in middle school, when I invited a friend to visit my home in Lanakila Housing, he got creeped out when he saw the graffitti on the wall. He asked me "is this a dangerous neighborhood?"

My brother told me he had the same experience when he invited some middle school friends to our house.

(by the way, that middle school -Kawananakoa - had a mix of ghetto kids from Lanakila, as well as upper-class kids from Alewa, Nuuanu, Pacific Heights.  How's that for a clash of cultures?)

But for me, Lanakila Housing wasn't some scary place to avoid.

It was where, as a kid, I spent a lot of time just bouncing a ball in the backyard, not really to practice a sport, but just to bounce a ball. It was where I enjoyed watching the rain make the backyard look like a swamp. It was where the neighbors used to greet me and my family. It was where my neighbors expressed pride when I won the elementary school's Geography Bee. It was where my grandma was also living, giving us access to oral history of Hawaii's past. It was where my mother grew up.   It was where I used to sit on the backyard bench and chill. It was where I used to be inside, read books, listen to radio and just chill. 

Does that sound scary to you?


Of course, the hood also had its alcoholics and drug addicts, domestic abuse cases, graffiti, gang members walking around drunk at night, and extremely loud house parties that kept neighbors awake. 


But the hood was more than just that! 

-----------------------------

Unfortunately, my parents were making too much income to stay in Lanakila Housing.  My mom was working in the bank, my dad was rising in the construction industry. After all, the complex was for "low-income" people.

And yes, I did say "Unfortunately, my parents were making too much income to stay in Lanakila Housing." 

To me, the hood wasn't some "scary place to avoid", it was the land of my childhood memories. 

My parents had to move. Unfortunately, they wanted to "buy a house" (really: be a sucker who allowed themselves to be stuck with a mortgage) in some suburb in another side of the island.

Duck Fat! 

At first, my parents moved me out there. I have never forgiven my parents for that decision! 


(I would've been much much more forgiving if they just found a place to rent nearby, which wasn't that hard to find)

Fortunately, my grandma sticked around the neighborhood. She lived there for decades, it's definitely much more than a "ghetto" for her, it was home. 

Fortunately for me, I was able to finish my high school career living with my grandma back in Lanakila Housing, instead of staying in a sucker suburb (trust me, I had much more offensive words to say about the suburbs than that)! 

-----------------------------------
So, it's not much mystery why some rappers and athletes still praise their childhood ghetto, even though they now make more $$$$$ than your average suburban resident.

Because to the rappers, athletes and your normal working person who grew up in the ghetto, the ghetto is more than just a scary place to avoid. It is a land of childhood memories, it is where they made wonderful memories with their friends, where they had neighbors who were like uncles and aunties, where they visited all the stores and had adventures in the park 

So even though many of us grew up and got legal incomes that put us in the middle class, we can't just brush away our ghetto past. Nor do we want to! 

---

Also, it's not much mystery why the Somali teenager was hiding in the airplane while trying to find a way back to Somalia. To him, Somalia is more than just "land of wars and famine" as is commonly portrayed in the US media. To him, it was his childhood home. I'm sure he had fun memories with childhood friends there, some great adventures that the average suburban American person can't relate to. Plus, he still have family there. I can't blame him. 



He was young, displaced and frustrated, and he wanted nothing more than to reunite with his mother in their native Africa. 
The 15-year-old Somali boy had been arguing at home, and in the kind of impulsive move that teenagers make, he hopped a fence at San Jose International Airport on April 20 and clambered into a wheel well of a Hawaii-bound jetliner. 
He survived the trip, and he has not spoken publicly about the ordeal. 
But his desperation and frustration — borne from a life in a new country and new culture, all of it without his mother — is becoming apparent through interviews with friends, family and law enforcement agents. 
The boy is "struggling adjusting to life in this country," his father, Abdul­ahi Yusuf, said in a statement issued Sunday through the Council on American-Islamic Relations' San Francisco Bay Area chapter.

Sunday, April 27, 2014

My Speech at Dr Knuth's Retirement Party

UH-Manoa's  Library and Information Science (LIS) professor  Dr. Rebecca Knuth is about to retire, and we had her retirement party earlier today.

Pablo Wegesend's photo
LIS professors 
Andrew Wertheimer and Rebecca Knuth (retiring)



This was my draft of the speech I gave


Hello everyone, my name is Pablo, I am a current student in the LIS program.


I want to thank Dr Knuth for being a great academic advisor and a great professor. I took her class in Intellectual Freedom last semester and I am taking her last class, History of Books and Libraries, this semester.


The overall themes of both classes include the importance of recording and storing information and the importance of allowing for the diversity of ideas and how we can’t take it for granted, knowing how vulnerable our libraries, archives, museums and even our computer systems are.


I know the LIS department is still in the process of finding the next professor. It is my hope that the next professor will have the same level of patience, open-mindedness, humility and friendliness that Dr Knuth has.


Dr Knuth, the LIS students will miss you greatly, and we wish you good luck in your new adventures.





Obviously, during a speech, most of us don't even read the draft word-for-word, we  deviate a bit from the speech, adding a few words and phrases.


But somewhere in my actual speech, I did mention that Dr Knuth was a living treasure and I mentioned a few things about the 2 of her books ("Libricide" and "Burning & Leveling Libraries"


But overall, my speech captured the spirit of the above draft!




Pablo Wegesend's photo
Me giving the  speech

---------------


There were also many other speeches at the party, some from colleagues, others from former and current students.


The most powerful speeches included one from a member of the alumni association, as well as one from a current LIS student who had her class in the past.


----


At the party, I saw a few of my current classmates, as well as a recent graduate from last year. I also some librarians I have recognized from visiting various public librarians. We all talked some stories and did some networking.


Thank you to everyone who organized this event. I really appreciate it!


--------------

BONUS PHOTO:


Pablo Wegesend's photos
Me and a few friends at the party!



Wednesday, April 16, 2014

In Memory of Francis (Sammy) Silva

I still remember the time in high school PE, when the sport of the day was indoor soccer. I volunteered to be the goalie. I was like "cool, I don't have to run around much". I was on cruise mode, then all of a sudden, one of the big football guys kicked the ball towards my goal ---- "oh ****, being a goalie wasn't as easy as I thought!"

I have just found out that classmate Francis JE Silva has just passed away! So far, what I heard (PLEASE correct me if any details are inaccurate) was that he got a heart attack and was in a coma.

Mr Silva, because he was big for his age, seemed intimidating at first. But he's a cool guy. Even the smallest member of the football team (hint, hint) told me nothing but positive things about Mr Silva!

Rest in peace, and condolences to your family Mr Silva!

The above was the facebook message I sent last night after finding out that Francis (aka Sammy) Silva passed away.


This sent shock-waves throughout the McKinley High School alumni community.

As I checked the various facebook messages about Mr Silva, the one thing keeps coming up: He  is known as the "gentle giant" ..............
...........(Unless, of course, you're at the wrong end of his indoor soccer goal)

Seriously though, Mr Silva was good person. He loved to play around and joke with people, but it was all in good fun.  I have never heard a single complaint about Mr Silva from my high school peers.

One of my close friends (Aaron G. -- who happened to be the smallest guy on the football team) told me that when him and Mr Silva were teammates,  Mr Silva was his protector.



Mr Silva was a lineman on the football team  and a team captain of the 1997 season. Silva, Solo, Viliami, Aukuso, Charlie, Imi, Mostella, Dae (and a few others I might've forgotten) were all stars on the best team McKinley High School had when I was a student there. The team had a hard act to follow after they graduated.

I also remember being in the audience at one of the team's games at Aloha Stadium, me and another student noticed how calm Mr Silva was, while another player was expressing his anger with full-blown rage.

Mr Silva also played on the school's basketball team as well.

The last time I met Silva in person was his high school graduation. He was a grade-level ahead of  me, so I was just in the audience congratulating him.

Years later, after I graduated high school, I was at a McKinley football game, me and Aaron G. noticed that Silva was one of the coaches on the sideline.   However, we never got a chance to get up close to meet & greet.

I did connect with Silva on facebook and we were on each other's friend's list, but we didn't chat much. But it did give us a chance to see each other's status updates, which by itself is a valuable thing.

Then sometime last year, Silva posted a video on facebook. One of his legs was amputated and there was now a prosthetic leg.   It was rumored (please correct me on any inaccuracies) that it was due to diabetes. It was freaked out many of our former classmates that one of the most physically strongest classmates was now in that condition.

And now, to find out that yesterday, first that he was in a hospital due to  heart-attack/coma and a few hours later, passed way.

Words can't express how tragic it is! You can't take life for granted!



Tuesday, April 08, 2014

Kurt Cobain -- 2 decades later

2 decades ago, Kurt Cobain committed suicide with a shotgun.




Cobain was the lead-singer of the rock band Nirvana.

KurtCobain.com
Kurt Cobain


Nirvana was part of what was then an emerging rock sub-genre called grunge, which came out of Seattle.


Grunge had element of punk, alternative and heavy metal, all mixed in a style that matched Seattle's gloomy, grey-skyed image.




Other bands in the grunge scene included Pearl Jam, Alice in Chains, Soundgarden, Meat Puppets and Candlebox




Nirvana started making records in the late 1980s but didn't hit mainstream until late 1991 when their biggest hit "Smells Like Teen Spirit". While that song had a more heavy metal sound, it was a symbol of the rise of alternative rock.




Scenes from 
"Smells Like Teen Spirit"
video





Around the same time, the most popular rock genre was hair metal, in which male rock stars had long, blonde hair. Those bands included Motley Crue, Guns N Roses, Warrant, and Poison.



Metallica was also popular, but they're were more like trash metal, whereas hair metal tend were more "pop + metal".



But with the rise of the grunge and alternative scenes, the "hair metal" scene started to fade.



MTV (which played music videos back then) started to play more grunge and  alternative rock.



While grunge has its masculine elements, alternative rock had a more feminized, soft image, which offended many heavy metal fans who believed rock music should be macho, tough, hard core and be ready for a fight. Alternative  was more about feeling sad and melancholy. Many heavy metal fans had a problem with that.  As you could see, this was part a major rivalry between various rock scenes.



-----

As for Kurt Cobain, he just wanted to play music.



When he started, his style of rock music wasn't mainstream.



But with his "Smell Like Teen Spirit" song and the "Nevermind", he became a rock star. He wasn't mentally prepared for that.  He wasn't mentally prepared to be recognized everywhere he went. It bothered him greatly.



Also, the fame and fortune could never erase his childhood traumas. His parents divorced and he moved around a lot when he was a child.  He had a hard pleasing his father who demanded to he played sports, when he preferred art & music.



Cobain also had chronic stomach-aches. The one thing  that " helped"?  Heroin. Of course, that brought in another set of problems.  He got addicted and survived an overdose in 1993.



He also had a troubled relationship with his wife, Courtney Love, who had her own band "Hole". Courtney Love behaved erratically.










 Kevin Mazur / WireImage
Kurt Cobain , Courtney Love with daughter Frances Bean in 1993








While Cobain proclaimed himself a "feminist" and criticized other rock stars for being misogynistic, he got into a fight with his wife, and the police arrested him. Based on what how Courtney Love usually acts, most people would later believe that she started the fight and Cobain defended himself.





Cobain was also a supporter of LGBT rights before it was even considered "cool".  At the time, gay rights was still considered a fringe thing. Cobain didn't care. Even though he was a heterosexual, he wasn't ashamed to have gay friends.





-----

In early April 1994, Kurt Cobain was missing. His bandmates couldn't find him. His wife couldn't find him. His friends and family couldn't find him





Then an electrician saw Kurt Cobain's body lying inside his home. Then he saw his shotgun.  Then he saw the note.

------

I still remember where I was when I heard the news. I was in 7th grade. I just came home and watched MTV, expecting to see music videos. Instead, there was news coverage of his suicide.




Then my friend Russell (who was a major rock fan) called. I thought "he is going to tell me that Kurt Cobain died."  He didn't even know, he just was calling to have another everyday conversation. He then turned on the TV and saw it for real.
---

Cobain's death  was heavily memorialized by many rock fans who lost their icon. Cobain was compared to other rock stars who died young  like Jimi Hendrix, Janis Joplin, Van Morrison and John Lennon.



However, even in death, his death was mocked.



Andy Rooney, who was the "60 Minutes" comic relief, had his segment mocking Cobain's fashion sense and his music. I still remember watching it and my dad being angry at Andy Rooney. My dad knew of Nirvana but wasn't a major fan. But the fact that Rooney mocked Cobain so shortly after his death was bad enough.



Rush Limbaugh called Kurt Cobain "worthless piece of human debris". But it was Rush Limbaugh, like Kurt Cobain, who turned to drugs to cure his pain. Whereas Cobain turned to heroin to cure his chronic stomach pains, Limbaugh turned to painkillers after multiple surgeries.





 Lesson: Be careful what you make fun of, it might soon be you!

Saturday, March 29, 2014

Stephen Colbert, Kim Phan and priorites

The thing about inside jokes is that people from the outside might take it the wrong way.

I mean, me and my friends had our inside jokes, and when guests come by and chill, they don't even get it! Sometimes, me and my friends have to remind each other to tone down the inside jokes when non-insiders are around!

Last year, Mountain Down had a TV ad with Odd Future, a rap group that is known for attention-grabbing outrageous lyrics. Unlike "reality rap" artists who say controversial stuff to make a bigger point, Odd Future just says stuff just to be silly. I mean who would take statements like “KILL PEOPLE, BURN SHIT, F___ SCHOOL,” or “go skate, rape sluts and eat donuts.” literally?

http://www.salon.com/2013/05/01/the_most_racist_commercial_of_all_time/

So Odd Future's Mountain Dew ad had a goat in a police lineup along with members of Odd Future. The goat threatens an older  woman viewing the police line-up.

You can call that style of humor all kinds of things --- vulgar, lame, idiotic.

However, Dr Boyce Watkins called that ad "the most racist racist commercial in history" as if Mountaint Dew just plucked a random group of African-American extras to portray criminal suspects in an ad to mock African-Americans, nevermind that the ad's idea itself came from Odd Future's leader Tyler the Creator!

It was an inside joke for Odd Future's fans!

But again, inside jokes aren't going to be understood by ad viewers who aren't familiar with Odd Future and their style of humor!

----

So on to Stephen Colbert, a well-known comedian who portrays an idiotic character on his Comedy Central. His character says all kind of silly stuff, and ask all kinds of silly questions to guest to get them to say something stupid. It's all part of an act!

It's called satire.

Or as Rush Limbaugh would call it -- "illustrating the absurd by being absurd!"

So Stephen Colbert was making fun of Dan Snyder, the owner of the NFL team Washington Redskins.

As you may know, many Native Americans feel the term "redskins" is a racist slur. They point out that nobody dares to call a team "blackskins", so why should we accept the term Redskins.

So Dan Snyder is now starting an outreach group called "Washington Redskins Original Americans Foundation" as a charity organization to assist Native Americans.

Well the name "Washington Redskins Original Americans Foundation" a fuel for satire by Stephen Colbert.

By illustrating the absurd by being absurd, Colbert's character says

“I am willing to show #Asian community I care by introducing the Ching-Chong Ding-Dong Foundation for Sensitivity to Orientals or Whatever.”

It was pure satire, illustrating Dan Snyder's absurdity by pointing how it would sound if another ethnic outreach group had an absurd title!

The same quote was Tweeted on Stephen Colbert's account (run by Comedy Central)

OMG, those who didn't get the inside joke over-reacted!

Internet pundit Suey Park started a #CancelCorbet campaign, acting as if Stephen Colbert was some anti-Asian bully making a joke ridiculing Asians, nevermind that it was obvious to the audience that it was a satire making fun of clueless racist people!


And guess what?

Suey Park doesn't speak for most Asian-Americans!

There were a whole bunch of Asian-Americans who think that Suey Park doesn't get satire and that she is overly sensitive!

 http://www.scpr.org/blogs/multiamerican/2014/03/29/16229/cancel-colbert-twitter-suey-park-hashtag/

"In an ideal world, anyone should be able to point out that yellow face is wrong,"  said Ti, who is Chinese-American. "It’s not hard."
But Ti questioned whether all Twitter campaigns are equally constructive. He for one, thought the campaign against The Colbert Report, was not worth all the angst.
There is a part of Asian-American community that I wish would pick its battles a little bit more and focus,” Ti said.











Another sign that Suey Park doesn't speak for most Asian-Americans.


I have seen ZERO people on my facebook NewsFeed wanting to #CancelCobert, even though my facebook list includes graduates from McKinley High School (which has the largest Asian immigrant population in all of Hawaii, and whose district includes Chinatown and Ke'eaumoku [aka Koreatown])

Plus, my university (UH-Manoa) has a large Asian-American population, my state (Hawaii) has a large Asian-American population, and the same with my  various worksites (mostly schools, with their mostly  Japanese-American staff)


Apparently, all my Asian-American friends have more important priorities than Suey Park does.


-----------

If Suey Park, as well as other trolls like Brittney Cooper and Randa Jarrar were really about fighting racist, then why were they silent about the brutal beating death of Kim Phan?


Kim Phan, a  23-year old Vietnamese-American woman, was brutally beaten by 2 Latinas outside of a Orange County nightclub!

photo by Christine Cotter/AP
 (From left to right) Marisol Meza, Ruben Mata and Tony Galvan stop to look at a street-side memorial for Kim Pham. Local businesses and the city’s government have drummed up $10,000 for information leading to the arrests of all suspects.


 http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime/arrest-made-beating-death-kim-pham-santa-ana-nightclub-article-1.1590642

Many people are hesitant to call the incident a "hate crime". I'm not!

I will say that the beating death of Kim Phan was a hate crime committed by racist Latina bullies!  


It's no secret that there are Latino vs Asian gang rivalries in many inner-city neighborhoods in California. .

It's no secret that many Asian gangs have started for the purpose of protecting themselves from Latino gangs!

But many "progressives" are hesitant to say anything about Latino racists (besides a so-called "white Latino" in Florida)  because they don't want to be seen as anti-Latino!

No, they only want to push a narrative of "white racism" and go to great depths to portray white belly dancers and white rappers as "cultural appropriation".

Nevermind that in the 1992 LA riots, Korean stores got looted, and none of the looters were neo-Nazi skinheads nor neo-Confederate wanabees.They were looted by African-American and Latinos.

Nevermind that that an African-American teenager  Latasha Harlins, who was racially profiled and shot in the head, wasn't killed by a neo-Nazi nor the KKK. She was profiled and killed by a Korean store owner

Nevermind that an African-American teenager Cheryl Green was gunned down in cold blood by racist gang members. And no, the gang wasn't KKK nor Aryan Brotherhood!  It was a Mexican-American gang!


And again, back to Kim Phan, she wasn't attacked by neo-Nazis or the KKK!

Her death had NOTHING to do with so-called cultural appropriation. Her death had NOTHING to do with Stephen Colbert's satire. Her death had NOTHING to do with "white privilege".


If Suey Park, Brittney Cooper, Veronica Bayetti Flores and Randa Jarrar really cared about social justice, they would stand up for Kim Phan!

They would take a strong stand against violent  racist bullies (and not only the KKK, Aryan Brotherhood or the police)!

They would take a strong stand against real racism, instead of misinterpreting an inside joke from a satire show!

They would encourage cultural exchanges, instead of whining and hating on white belly dancers and white rappers winning awards!


But that's not how Suey Park, Brittney Cooper, Veronica Bayetti Flores  and Randa Jarrar roll!
 They are just trolls

(i know, it rhymes)

To hell with them!

Thursday, March 20, 2014

Reader response on cultural appopriation

The past two days, I wrote 2 blog posts about this "cultural appropriation" nonsense.
 http://pablowegesend.blogspot.com/2014/03/cultural-appopriation-and-cultural.html
http://pablowegesend.blogspot.com/2014/03/cultural-appopriation-and-cultural_19.html


Now, I got an email from a blog reader. It was in response to what I said about Randa Jarrar, the Arab-American women who wrote 2 articles stating she  "can't stand white belly dancers".  Jarrar claims it's bad that "white people" to participate in "non-white" cultural things because "whites oppress and steal cultures" and that it's OK for "non-whites" to participate in "white" cultural things because "white oppress and steal cultures"


It is classic!


There doesn't seem to be a place to leave comments on your blog, so I'm sending one here.  Your part about belly dancing being appropriated by the Arabs from other cultures got me thinking, didn't the Arabs appropriate the Old Testament (and much of the base content used in Islam) from Christianity and Judaism?  


Also, the Arabs occupied Spain and Portugal for 700 or so years, and I think invaded Sicily at some point as well, so even if whats her names point about Europeans not being able to use the cultural traits of those other Europeans colonized was valid, which it isn't, the same point could be made that Europeans of Spanish, Portuguese and Sicilian descent have the same relationship to Arabs as Jarrar says Arabs have to Europeans.  Also, although not the dominant group per se, the Arabs were also significant in the Ottoman Empire which controlled Greece and several other Eastern European countries for several hundred years. For that matter, Arabs were practicing slavery in Africa centuries before the Europeans discovered the Americas!


Thank you!


The problem with all these "cultural appropriation" whiners is that they say "learn your history", but it is them that need to learn history!

These "cultural appropriation" whiners think history is just about evil white Europeans picking on peaceful non-white peoples.

History is a lot more complicated than that! 


All over the world, tribes were conquering, killing (even to the point of genocide) and enslaving rival tribes.

What do you think the Aztecs, Zulus, Arabs, Turks, Incas, and a whole bunch of other tribes were doing before the Europeans came to their territory? 

They were raping and pillaging and enslaving and all the other bad stuff! Off course, many of those cultures also built great civilizations and contributed to education, art and a whole bunch of other good stuff! No culture is totally perfect nor totally evil!


The only thing got the Europeans to conquer the most was they were the first to make really advanced ships (to bring mass # of troops, settlers, etc to far, far, far away) and to use firearms and explosives so effectively. Also, they were able to run into isolated populations (ie Native Americans, Pacific Islanders) that haven't had the chance to gain immunity to diseases.

And it wasn't even all European populations, it was just a few European countries (ie France, Britain, Spain, Portugal, Netherlands, Belgium and Germany) that did so!

Meanwhile, other European nations (ie Ireland, Latvia, Lithuania, Estonia, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Slovenia, Ukraine, Belarus) spent most of the last few centuries being being conquered by nearby European powers.

But OMG if someone of Latvian, Irish or Ukrainian descent decided to do something "non-white" like belly dance, have corn-rows or wear a kimono. Because chumps like Randa Jarrar and Brittney Cooper says  "history says white people are all oppressors who conquer, oppress and steal cultures"? Fool, you learn your history!

By the way, the only great powers in this world is USA (mostly white, but has a half-African descendant as president, plus has a growing non-white population), Russia (white-run nation gaining their power back), and China.  

Iran is a regional power scaring people, but is nowhere near taking over the world. It is mostly a threat to nearby nations, just so happen that one of them was a refuge for Holocaust survivors!  

India is a rising power, but they don't really care about expanding its military power to outside lands. They're more concerned about Pakistan being taken over by fanatics.

Other than Russia, the rest of Europe has no real military power. It's mostly nations free-loading off US might!  European empires are over! All they got left are a few territories that don't even have enough natural resources to prosper in the modern world! And even then, some of those territories have their own sovereignty movement (ie. French-run Tahiti) which can make it likely that the Europeans will continue to retreat even more!

Sheesh, even North Korea (the poor half of Korea) is a much bigger threat than all these European empires of the past.  Nobody is scared of Netherlands or Portugal anymore! But people fear a North Korean attack!

So Randa Jarrar and Brittney Cooper need to learn their history and learn the present! Europeans were only conquering far away lands for just a few centuries (compared to multiple millenniums, most of which, the Europeans were far behind Middle East and East Asia in advancement, power and prestige) and are basically retreating to their own shell (with Russia as the only exception).

And even in the US, white power has declined. Randa Jarrar and Brittney Cooper can point out some stories of hate crimes, but most crime is where the predator and victim are the same race. I discussed that issue at http://pablowegesend.blogspot.com/2013/07/the-fear-of-other.html.

At this point, white belly dancers and white rappers just want to have fun. Just like how Aloe Blacc and Darius Rucker just want to have fun in mostly Euro-American music genres.

Let's all enjoy each other's culture's.

As Rodney King said "Can't we all just get along?"

Wednesday, March 19, 2014

Cultural appopriation and cultural integration (part2)

Yesterday, I had a blog post about "cultural appropriation" which is a code word for "how dare those white folks use cultural practices from non-white cultures"
http://pablowegesend.blogspot.com/2014/03/cultural-appopriation-and-cultural.html


Well, lo and behold, Randa Jarrar the same racist punk who didn't like "white belly dancers" is back at it again.
http://www.salon.com/2014/03/18/i_still_cant_stand_white_belly_dancers/

Here is her sorry excuse for "logic"


“So black women can’t be ballerinas?” If black women were part of a dominant culture that had colonized Europe starting at the Italian renaissance, and later colonized France and Russia, and if, after all that, black ballerinas danced in bikini tops, then yes, this argument would work. But it doesn’t.
“I’m Egyptian and I love white belly dancers!” Good for you. Come live in America for 23 years, have people throw lit cigarettes at you and make fun of your mother’s accent and sneer at your muhajjaba aunt and try to deport your brother, see a white woman be applauded in a bar while dancing to “Walk Like an Egyptian” in a “Nefertiti hat,” and if, after that, you still feel the same way, cool, write your own opinion piece about it.
“You’re an idiot! America is a melting pot!” Yes, America pretends to be a melting pot, but this means everyone has to adhere to a cultural norm, and in the process, minorities are negated and further made invisible.
“It’s appreciation, not appropriation!” No. Please read this for more about appreciation vs. appropriation.
“But Korean tacos! Mixing cultures is delicious!” Again, if the person making and serving those tacos is from a dominant culture that, for centuries, colonized Korea and Mexico, and then served those tacos to you in a conical Asian hat and a mariachi outfit, with a bikini top underneath, then, yeah, this argument would work. Again, it doesn’t.
”You’re a racist!” Please, save us both time, watch this, and learn how that’s not possible.
“You’re appropriating white culture by using a computer right now!” I can’t even honor this level of idiocy and entitlement with a response.

In other words, Randa Jarrar is saying "how dare you ask me to be consistent. How dare you ask me to stop using double standards?"


Randa Jarrar is a racist punk who stereotypes all European-Americans, as if they are all the same. She thinks that just because a few "white" kids who teased during childhood, she assumes all "white people" are out to humiliate "her people".

This so goes against Martin Luther King's plea to judge people based not on the color of their skin, but by the content of their character!

But to Randa Jarrar, all Europeans are out to conquer and oppress, nevermind that countries like Lativa, Lithuania, Estonia, Ukraine, Belarus, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Switzerland, Slovenia and Ireland HAVE NEVER CONQUERED A SINGLE NON-WHITE LAND!

But if any of their descendants do anything non-European, Randa Jarrar will accuse them of "cultural appropriation" all because a bunch of British, French, Spanish, Portuguese, Dutch and Germans were conquering large land masses before our generation were even born?

That's as stupid as saying "the Koreans bombed Pearl Harbor". That's as stupid as Floyd Mayweather telling Manny Pacquaio to "make sushi". 

Meanwhile, the Arabs (Randa Jarrar's people), the Aztecs, the Zulus, and so many other ethnic tribes have been conquering and oppressing other tribes for years until the Europeans did the same exact thing to them! 

But all that reality gets ignored in this politically correct world, in which "white people" are made to feel unearned guilt in participating in "non-white" activities.

Nevermind that Macklemore won an award in a genre that borrowed HEAVILY from Kraftwerk (a German EDM pioneering group that inspired Grandmaster Flash, Afrika Bambaata, and Dr. Dre...........ask them if you dont believe me) 

Randa Jarrar calls any arguments against her "whitesplaining" (even though in my case, my German last name came from my mom, and my dad is not only from Mexico, but is a dark brown native Mexican!)


Just like I mentioned in a previous blog post..................... just like how NFL star Richard Sherman feels that calling him a "thug" is just another way of calling him the N-word.................................

................................words like  "cultural appropriation" and "whitesplaining" is just another way to call someone a "f------ haole" or a "white cracker m-----f-----"

Again, this goes against the spirit of Martin Luther King's dream of having people judged NOT on the color of the skin, but by the content of their character!

Sadly, towards the end of King's life, he was seen as an "Uncle Tom" by militant activists because of  his nonviolent tactics, and his refusal to hate European-Americans!  Nevermind that his ways saved our country from a bloody race war!

But people like Randa Jarrar, Brittney Cooper, Veronica Bayetti Flores and other scumbags don't want a post-racial society, they want racial conflict!

They pick easy targets like "white belly dancers", Macklemore, Miley Cyrus, Lorde .........all of whom would never be defended by the white nationalists nor the Fox News crowd. 

They are afraid to pick fights with someone like Eminem who is great at the art of the  insults, and has D-12,  Dr Dre and 50 Cent to back him up! 

But their bullying ways will come back to haunt them!  

However, just dont take my word for it.

Here are some classic comments to Randa Jarrar's latest piece of trash.

 



Notice how she ignores all the reasonable arguments against her first piece and responds only to the ridiculous, irrational reactions.  Arabs have also enslaved and colonized and appropriated, as people point out.  Some white women who 'belly dance' study the culture and music and don't confuse gauzy pants and blue eye shadow with genuine Middle Eastern dance attire.  But never mind.  Jarrar is determined to be the victim while all white belly dancers are the oblivious cultural  appropriators.  So let her.




A few questions. Do you see a difference between appropriation and cultural exchange? The latter has been happening for as long as us humans have had cultures to exchanged.

Also, some context would be nice. Belly Dancing is originally an art form of the Dom people. The Dom people are "gyspys" related to the Roma people in Europe. Both are originally South Asian.

Any qualms about Arabs "appropriating" a cultural tradition that is not theirs? Or is that cultural exchange?

What about the Arab appropriation of the Indian numeral system? I can't tell you how many times I've heard Arabs boast of inventing the zero. Well no, you didn't. You borrowed it from the Indians. Which is normal, and its how knowledge works. But would you consider that appropriation?

 Quite seriously, there are more important things to worry about for us people of color than white women wearing Saris and Bindis and performing Belly Dance.

You've given plenty of examples of actually racist behavior in this essay too. And I'm 100% in agreement with your analysis that PoC participating in the dominant white culture is not the same as appropriation. I just don't agree that Belly Dancing or wearing Saris is appropriation. If it is, so was Belly Dancing when it was adopted by Arabs from the Dom people.







@Khawer  That was one of the responses from the original article that she neglected to respond to.  The author is, in effect, a troll.



Dear Mrs. Jarrar,

I only have one complaint to the responses you've included in your defense of your previous article. I am dismayed by the way you refused to consider the notion that you are being racist.

You liked to a video on "reverse racism" which is a BS term in itself, something I feel you and I could agree on. Racism is racism, it doesn't change the fact if it is a white man hating a black man for the color of his skin, or a black woman hating a hispanic woman for the color of her skin, or arabic peoples hating jewish peoples, or Ukrainians hating Russians. If you look at another human being and you say, "how dare you do that, you're not the same race as me" you are indeed being racist.

There's no "reverse" to the matter, it is racism. And the fact that you took criticism of your own racism, and said that it is not possible because- I assume since you didn't personally address the issue- you have darker skin then the people you are attacking, proves that the crux of your argument hinges on the notion that race defines culture.

You, several times in this article, explain why you can't stand a certain race doing a cultural dance, due to the fact that individuals of that race have, in turn, treated you cruelly due to your ancestry. This is textbook stereotyping of race, and the fact that you couldn't brave addressing this notion in a rational way taints your entire argument with the racial divisiveness that your title promises.

I am not addressing an issue of privilege. I am not addressing the appropriation of cultures. I am addressing the most fundamental definition of racism. You judge other's in a way that you have yourself been judged, by the color of their skin and the history of your ancestors. I am sorry if you refuse to see the fact, but you are a racist.

AMEN to all that!

Just don't expect the Randa Jarrars or the Brittney Coopers of the world to respond with real logic.  Just more abuse of sarcasms, race cards and double standards!

Some say "don't feed the trolls"  I say "feed the trolls with a taste of their own medicine"  The more people who do that, the less people who want to start trolling!